Tag CIO Influence

Is the Role of CIO Ascending or Descending?

Reading through the abundant content on the topics of “partnership” and “alignment” between IT and business units, it’s easy to get a little dispirited.  In survey after survey:
From the Business perspective, we hear that there is a large communication divide between IT and business units, that IT doesn’t understand the business, that IT staff don’t have the necessary skills to think beyond simple black and white (as proven by their Myers-Briggs scores), that they are still thinking in bits and bytes instead of business solutions, that they lack the communication and marketing skills to translate IT investments into business strategies, and can’t move fast enough to keep up with those changing strategies anyway…
From the IT perspective, we hear that the business is difficult to work with, that they only treat IT as a service organization and not as strategic partners, that their business “strategy” is really just a series of tactical projects that become a strategy in hindsight, that the business doesn’t understand the need for “infrastructure”, that IT only learns about the organization’s plans well downstream from when they were envisioned, and that IT may not have the “seat at the table” it requires to be a real strategic partner anyway…
Much as it’s possible to tune into a soap opera and see the same character hooked up to that hospital room ventilator after missing a year’s worth of episodes, we see these studies repeated each year, with eerily similar results.
Paging Dr. Phil?

The Influence Game for New CIOs

The real impact that a new CIO will have after joining an organization is largely driven by that individuals leadership skills and ability to deliver, but is also framed by other factors, including:

  • The perceived role of the CIO as held by the reporting point. Is it the CEOs expectation that the CIO will be primarily a technical manager that can hold their own at an occasional staff meeting, or a polished leader who is as comfortable in the Boardroom as in the data center? Is it somewhere in-between? The consensus definition of the role of the CIO, if there is one, has changed over the years, with substantial variation by industry and company. One organization’s CIO is another’s tactical data center manager, and is another’s strategic thought partner.
  • The expectations of C-level peers and business customers. What has their experience been with the prior CIO at this company, or at prior companies? Do they bring an expectation of being able to partner with the new CIO based on prior experience, or will the first meeting with them be viewed as an opportunity to hand over a long list of demands, perhaps even including their plan to drive the engagement model for IT services?
  • The historical success of the IT department within the company. What is the institutionalized view of the IT team’s historical performance? Are high expectations already in place based on prior performance, or is there a sense among the executive team that the IT shop has not delivered in the past? Upon taking the new position, will the CIO be digging the IT shop out of a reputation hole, or is IT perhaps on the CFO’s short list for planned investment cuts?